Home  »  Analysis  •  Business News

JetBlue and Spirit Airlines’ $3.8 Billion Merger Faces Legal Delays: An In-Depth Analysis

3rd February, 2024| By Business Desk
Spirit Airlines Plane
Spirit Airlines Plane | Credit: Wikimedia Commons
  • JetBlue Airways and Spirit Airlines face a setback as the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Boston schedules their merger appeal hearing for June, a month later than desired.
  • Originating from a Justice Department lawsuit last year, the legal dispute centers on concerns that the $3.8 billion merger would diminish competition and raise fares, leading to a federal district judge in Boston blocking the deal in January.
  • The airlines sought an expedited appeal due to an impending July 24 closing date in their merger agreement. Failure to expedite the process may result in lost benefits if the agreement terminates before a court decision.
  • JetBlue expressed doubts about meeting merger conditions and warned of potential termination. The airline evaluates cost-cutting measures amidst uncertainties, impacting its financial outlook.
  • The blocked merger leaves Spirit Airlines facing challenges, including weak demand and potential financial instability. Analysts suggest bankruptcy risks if finances are not stabilized, emphasizing broader implications for the airline industry.

JetBlue Airways and Spirit Airlines are facing a delay in their appeal process concerning the proposed $3.8 billion merger between the two carriers. The 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Boston has scheduled the appeal hearing for June, a month later than the airlines had initially sought. The airlines had requested an expedited hearing in May to meet the merger agreement’s July 24 deadline for deal closure. The appeal court directed the filing of pre-hearing briefs by February 26, with the U.S. Justice Department’s response due by April 11.

This legal battle originated from the Justice Department’s lawsuit filed last year, aiming to block the merger, asserting that it would diminish competition and result in increased fares, particularly impacting travelers relying on low-cost Spirit Airlines. In January, a federal district judge in Boston ruled in favor of the government, citing antitrust law violations and halting the proposed deal.

JetBlue, headquartered in New York, had contended that the merger would enhance its competitiveness against larger airlines. However, the appeal now faces challenges due to ongoing losses and other complications at Spirit Airlines, based in Miramar, Florida. JetBlue issued a warning last week, indicating a potential termination of the agreement.

In a separate filing, JetBlue Airways and Spirit Airlines jointly petitioned the First U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for an expedited appeal to reverse the lower court’s decision that thwarted their $3.8 billion merger. The airlines argued that the lower court ruling disregarded the transaction’s benefits to the majority of the flying public.

The joint court filing emphasized the urgency of an expedited appeal, highlighting the impending July 24 closing date set by the merger agreement. If the appeal process is not expedited, there is a risk that the court may not have the opportunity to review the decision before the specified closing date. The airlines asserted that if the merger agreement terminates before the court’s decision, the anticipated benefits of the deal would be lost.

Despite the uncertainties surrounding the merger, JetBlue expressed doubts about meeting certain conditions required under the agreement for unspecified reasons. While JetBlue is assessing options within the framework of the agreement, it committed to abiding by its merger obligations unless the agreement is terminated. In response, Spirit Airlines affirmed that there was no basis for terminating the merger agreement and expected JetBlue to honor its obligations.

The cancellation of the JetBlue deal poses challenges for Spirit Airlines, an ultra-low-cost carrier already grappling with weak demand in key markets. Some analysts have even raised the possibility of bankruptcy if the airline fails to stabilize its finances. A U.S. judge’s recent decision to block the planned merger emphasized concerns about potential threats to competition in the domestic aviation market and adverse effects on ticket prices.

Against this backdrop, JetBlue announced its evaluation of deeper cost-cutting measures as it anticipates a decline in revenue and increased costs in the first quarter. The airline attributed these challenges to uneven travel demand, underscoring the broader impact of market dynamics on carriers’ financial outlook.